Before telling you about this Homemade Vegan Popcorn Tin we gotta go to that good ol’ disclaimer: Housevegan.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. This post contains Amazon affiliate links.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f1d0b/f1d0b7a3ab27af776cd0f1e2d59b07fb4503cd82" alt="Homemade Vegan Popcorn Tin featuring "Buttered" & Salted, Cheezy, and Cinnamon Toast Popcorn - So delicious for a vegan holiday snack! homemade popcorn tin homemade popcorn tins vegan popcorn tin vegan popcorn tins homemade vegan popcorn tin coconut oil popcorn topping coconut oil popcorn recipe coconut oil popcorn ratio coconut oil popcorn seasoning coconut oil popcorn coconut oil and popcorn coconut oil as popcorn topping coconut oil popcorn recipe air popper popcorn with coconut oil and sea salt popcorn with coconut oil and nutritional yeast coconut oil popcorn cinnamon coconut oil cooking popcorn coconut oil caramel popcorn recipe coconut oil cinnamon popcorn recipe coconut oil popcorn diet drizzle coconut oil on popcorn easy coconut oil popcorn coconut oil for popcorn coconut oil for popcorn healthy coconut oil for popcorn on stove coconut oil good for popcorn does coconut oil make good popcorn coconut oil popcorn healthy coconut oil popcorn how to coconut oil hot air popcorn coconut oil and himalayan salt popcorn recipe coconut oil in popcorn coconut oil in popcorn maker is coconut oil popcorn healthy is coconut oil good on popcorn coconut oil popcorn kettle corn popcorn kernels coconut oil coconut oil popcorn movie theater coconut oil popcorn maker coconut oil popcorn machine recipe coconut oil popcorn mix coconut oil making popcorn popcorn coconut oil nutritional yeast nutiva coconut oil popcorn coconut oil popcorn on stove coconut oil on popcorn coconut oil on popcorn healthy melted coconut oil on popcorn coconut oil popped popcorn coconut oil popped popcorn calories whirley pop popcorn with coconut oil perfect coconut oil popcorn coconut oil popcorn refined coconut oil popcorn topping recipe coconut oil popcorn stovetop coconut oil popcorn sweet coconut oil popcorn salt coconut oil spice popcorn coconut oil popcorn taste coconut oil to popcorn ratio coconut oil to popcorn coconut oil popcorn on the stove coconut oil movie theatre popcorn coconut oil uses popcorn use coconut oil for popcorn vegan coconut oil popcorn coconut oil popcorn whirley coconut oil with popcorn popcorn coconut oil with butter flavor cooking with coconut oil popcorn popcorn with coconut oil coconut oil nutritional yeast popcorn popcorn coconut oil yeast vegan cheesy popcorn seasoning vegan cheese popcorn vegan cheese popcorn recipe vegan cheesy popcorn vegan cheesy popcorn recipe nutritional yeast popcorn topping nutritional yeast popcorn without oil nutritional yeast popcorn oil nutritional yeast cheese popcorn cheesy nutritional yeast popcorn best nutritional yeast popcorn recipe nutritional yeast popcorn nutritional yeast popcorn topping recipe nutritional yeast popcorn vegan nutritional yeast and popcorn nutritional yeast and popcorn recipe best nutritional yeast popcorn nutritional yeast cheesy popcorn popcorn nutritional yeast coconut oil nutritional yeast for popcorn nutritional yeast sauce for popcorn get nutritional yeast stick popcorn how to make nutritional yeast popcorn homemade popcorn nutritional yeast healthy popcorn nutritional yeast nutritional yeast in popcorn make nutritional yeast stick popcorn nutritional yeast on popcorn nutritional yeast on popcorn recipe sprinkle nutritional yeast on popcorn how to put nutritional yeast on popcorn nutritional yeast on microwave popcorn nutritional yeast air popped popcorn nutritional yeast popcorn recipe nutritional yeast popcorn recipe vegan nutritional yeast popcorn seasoning recipe nutritional yeast popcorn seasoning stovetop popcorn nutritional yeast nutritional yeast won't stick to popcorn savory popcorn nutritional yeast nutritional yeast stick to popcorn how to add nutritional yeast to popcorn using nutritional yeast on popcorn nutritional yeast with popcorn popcorn with nutritional yeast recipe"
Merry Christmas, friends! This holiday has been busy busy busy this year. In fact, I’m writing this from my Oma’s house to the sound of laughter and total dorkiness from my family behind me. This is our first Christmas home in two years, and it’s been lovely so far. My Oma’s house is like a hub for our whole family, and it’s really great to be here again eating our weight in snacks and cozying up on the couch amidst my Oma’s extensive old world Santa Claus collection. German Christmas is so magical, y’all.
One thing I’ll always remember about Christmas at Oma’s was those fun popcorn tins. Remember those? They were huge tins filled with butter popcorn, cheese popcorn, and caramel corn. Us kids (me, my sister, and our gazillion cousins) would go so crazy for popcorn tins that our parents just started getting us each our own. Staying home for Christmas for the first time in forever had me thinking about Christmasses past, and inevitably these popcorn tins popped into my mind.
It’s kind of silly to call this a recipe, but if you ever loved popcorn tins then this post is for you! Below is my favorite way to make “buttered” popcorn as well as recipes for noochy/cheesy popcorn sprinkle, and cinnamon toast popcorn. Of course, you could make any popcorn recipe that you like, and use my ratios as a guide. I will say that my basic “buttered” and salted popcorn is pretty dope. I use coconut oil, and it tastes legit.
For the three compartment divider, I never did come up with a clean enough method that would be worthy of sharing here. Basically I watched this video over and over, and sort of engineered something out of poster board. However, if you come up with an easier method, let me know.
Happy Holidays, dear readers?!
Mentioned in this recipe:
Homemade Vegan Popcorn Tin w/ “Buttered” & Salted, Cheezy, and Cinnamon Toast Popcorn
Ingredients
- 1/4 cup brown sugar
- 1/4 teaspoon cinnamon
- 2 tablespoons fine sea salt
- 1/4 cup nutritional yeast
- 1 teaspoon garlic powder
- 1 teaspoon onion powder
- 1/4 teaspoon mustard powder
- 5 tablespoons refined coconut oil, room temperature
- 1 tablespoon vanilla syrup
- 1 1/4 cups unpopped popcorn
- 5 tablespoons refined coconut oil, melted
- 2 gallon popcorn tin
Instructions
1. In a small bowl combine the brown sugar, cinnamon, and 1 teaspoon of the salt. Set this mixture aside. In another small bowl combine the nutritional yeast, garlic powder, onion powder, mustard powder, and 2 teaspoons of the salt. Set this mixture aside as well.
2. In a large stock pot with a lid melt the room temperature coconut oil over medium heat. Add three popcorn kernels to the oil, and cover the pot. When you hear the first popcorn kernel pop pour in the remaining popcorn kernels. Cover the popcorn, and vigorously shake the pot over the stove eye to pop the popcorn. Continue to pop the popcorn until the popping slows down significantly or stops. Pull the pot off of the heat.
3. To make the Cinnamon Toast Popcorn: Transfer 10 cups of the popped popcorn to a large paper shopping bag. Drizzle the vanilla syrup and 1 tablespoon of the melted coconut oil over the popcorn, close the bag well, and shake well to coat each kernel. Open the bag, and pour in the brown sugar/cinnamon mixture. Re-close the bag and shake the popcorn to coat.
4. To make the Vegan Cheesy Popcorn: Transfer 10 cups of the popped popcorn to a large paper shopping bag. Drizzle 2 tablespoons of the melted coconut oil over the popcorn, close the bag well, and shake well to coat each kernel. Open the bag, and pour in the nutritional yeast mixture. Re-close the bag and shake the popcorn to coat.
5. To make the Vegan “Buttered” and Salted Popcorn: Drizzle the remaining melted coconut oil over the popcorn remaining in the stock pot, cover the pot with the lid, and carefully shake to pot well to coat each kernel. Add the remaining salt to the popcorn, re-cover the pot, and shake the popcorn to coat.
6. Taste each popcorn batch for salt. Add the popcorn to your tin accordingly!